Assessing the Risks of Binance: Is it Safe to Use?

Binance: Should You Be Worried?

Binance is a major player within the cryptocurrency industry, having risen to prominence in 2017 as part of the Initial Coin Offering (ICO) boom. However, concerns have been raised about the centralization of Binance Coin (BNB) and recent legal actions brought by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), leading some to question whether this cryptocurrency giant could be headed for a FTX-like scenario.

The Success of Binance’s ICO

In 2017, Binance launched an ICO as a means of raising capital for its cryptocurrency exchange. Binance issued a total of 200 million BNB tokens, with 40% being allocated to the founding team for future development and marketing efforts. BNB tokens were bought by investors with the expectation that their value would increase as Binance grew.

Investors who held BNB tokens also received a discount on the platform’s fees. Every quarter, Binance used 20% of its profits to buy back BNB tokens and burn them, thereby reducing the supply of tokens. The remaining BNB tokens were intended to be used to pay the fees for Binance’s future decentralized platform, the Binance Chain, once it was built.

Is BNB a Security?

Despite the intended use case for BNB, regulators began to question whether it qualified as a security under federal securities laws due to its resemblance to one according to the Howey test. However, Binance did not take the necessary steps to register and disclose the token with the SEC.

While Binance’s founder, CZ, stated that BNB was not a security, his claim was dubious, as the existence of BNB on a decentralized blockchain did not necessarily make it uncontrollable. Binance launched its own blockchain, Binance Chain, in 2019, which was initially highly centralized. This centralization was intended to be temporary, with Binance gradually decentralizing the blockchain as the ecosystem grew.

The PoSA and Binance’s Control

One feature of the Binance Chain is the Proof of Staked Authority (PoSA), a consensus mechanism that relies on validators to verify transactions. Validators are required to stake BNB tokens as collateral to participate, with the amount of BNB staked determining their influence on the network. This means that Binance retains significant control over the blockchain, as it is a large holder of BNB tokens.

In September 2020, Binance launched the Binance Smart Chain (BSC), which was fueled by BNB tokens. The Binance Chain was renamed the Beacon Chain and was used for governance and decision-making platforms. The two chains merged in February 2022 to form the BNB Chain, which consists of the BNB Beacon Chain and the BNB Smart Chain.

Should You Be Worried?

The recent legal actions brought by the CFTC against Binance have raised concerns about the company’s future. Additionally, the centralization of Binance’s blockchain and the control that Binance retains over the BNB tokens are worrying factors.

While Binance has stated its intention to gradually decentralize the Binance Chain, it remains to be seen how successful this will be. Ultimately, the decision of whether to invest in Binance or use its services is a personal one that should be based on careful consideration of the risks and benefits.